Tomato Cheddar Soup with Garlic Cheese Toasts

Tomato Cheddar Soup with Garlic Cheese Toasts

Weather: rain puddles and two moose in the yard
What I’m listening to: Dancing in the Minefields, Andrew Peterson

This first week of school has brought a distinct chill in the air and some rather heavy rains. It has been perfect soup weather. But, I still wanted to give a couple of final nods to summer with the bright flavors of tomato and basil, especially since I know a great many of my readers are still experiencing sweltering heat and plentiful gardens.

Tomato Cheddar Soup with Cheese Toasts via Alaska from Scratch

Tomato Cheddar Soup with Cheese Toasts via Alaska from Scratch

Tomato Cheddar Soup with Cheese Toasts via Alaska from Scratch

One of my kids’ favorite meals is grilled cheese sandwiches with tomato soup for dipping (and let’s be honest – mom and dad are fans, too). I have long been fond of the combination of tomato soup and cheddar. I knew when I saw this recipe on Foodgawker that it would be my first soup of the season.

Tomato Cheddar Soup with Cheese Toasts via Alaska from Scratch

Why had I never thought to incorporate cheddar into the soup itself? It’s genius, really. A perfect match. I was also intrigued by the use of yogurt for creaminess instead of cream. And, I couldn’t forget to add a “grilled cheese” element to the meal (for the kids, of course… wink, wink), so I decided on garlic cheese toasts on homemade french bread. Now that’s mmm, mmm good.

Tomato Cheddar Soup with Cheese Toasts


Soup adapted from [More Fruit Please|]

Yields: 6-8 servings

  • For the Soup:
  • 2 (28-oz) cans diced tomatoes
  • 1 medium onion, chopped
  • 2 large cloves of garlic, chopped
  • 2T olive oil
  • 2c chicken broth
  • 1c plain yogurt (or plain Greek yogurt)
  • 1c cheddar cheese, grated
  • 1/2c basil, chopped, loosely packed
  • 2t sugar
  • pinch of red pepper flakes (or to taste)
  • salt and pepper to taste
  • For Cheese Toasts:
  • 1 loaf french bread, sliced
  • olive oil
  • 1 clove garlic, sliced in half
  • cheddar cheese, grated

!For the Soup:

To a soup pot over medium heat, add olive oil. Saute onions until tender, 3 minutes. Add garlic and cook another 1-2 minutes.

Pour in the cans of tomatoes (including juice) and the chicken broth. Stir in the basil, sugar, red pepper flakes, and salt and pepper. Bring to a simmer, reduce heat, cover and simmer 10 minutes.

Turn off heat and stir in the cheddar and yogurt until combined. Using an immersion blender or standard blender (working in batched, holding down the lid with a kitchen towel to prevent hot soup splatter), blend the soup until smooth.

Garnish with grated cheddar and basil. Serve with garlic cheese toasts.

!For Cheese Toasts:

Turn broiler on high. Place bread slices on a sheet pan. Rub french bread slices with the raw end of your garlic. Brush each slice lightly with olive oil. Toast 1-2 minutes until golden brown. Top with grated cheddar. Return to broiler until cheddar is melted and bubbly.


This recipe was great! I tend to use recipes as templates and change things to my taste, but this recipe was great as is. It was perfect for a cool, Fall evening in the mountains. Thanks!


Oh wow! This looks delicious! Planning to make it this week! Love your blog!!!!

Hannah Halleck
Hannah Halleck

Hi! I just discovered your website, and I'm very excited about all the delicious things you have here! I've been pinning like crazy! Thank you! I look forward to a little more variety in our menu! Hannah

Cassandra Dray Steinmann
Cassandra Dray Steinmann

Yeah I can't wait until its cooler here! Then I will definitely make this ( and with my mixer that I won!!;))

Alaska from Scratch
Alaska from Scratch

LOL Diane! Yeah we're 40-50 degrees cooler than you are right now. :)

Diane Ussery
Diane Ussery

OK, please repost this again when it's not 100+ outside....looks & sounds delish!!!

Bill McCoy
Bill McCoy

We dearly needed a tomato soup recipe - now if only we could get a little chill in the air to make us feel like making soup!

Alaska from Scratch
Alaska from Scratch

Welcome, Hannah! I'm so glad you found me. Happy cooking (and pinning). :)


  1. […] Tomato Cheddar Soup with Garlic Cheese Toasts – Alaska from Scratch What I Ate This Week + Maple Chipotle Squash Wedges Recipe As I said more quail eggs recipes are coming over the next few days. OK, I know this isn’t really a quail egg recipe, but I made some linguini and why not throw some quail eggs on top. This is how I came up with the name lazy linguini, because it’s a simple simple recipe, and because I just threw some quail eggs on top. So it’s lazy linguini!! I had to include this picture of the quail eggs again in this post, because I just think they are so adorable. Aren’t they? […]

  2. […] wanted some good homemade bread to make my Garlic Cheese Toasts to go along with my Tomato Cheddar Soup a couple of weeks back. I decided that I would try my hand at some French Bread. Having never made […]

  3. […] one of my favorite “rainy day treats” from when I was a kid.  Of course when I saw the idea to add cheese directly into tomato soup I had to try […]

  4. […] 3) Tomato cheddar soup […]


New Recipe Email

Join our mailing list to receive the latest recipe and updates from Alaska from Scratch.

~ Maya

You have Successfully Subscribed!

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This Recipe

We'd love for you to share this recipe with your friends!